In 2022, Paul went
viral for revealing that she and her husband had been "
soft-swinging" with other couples. According to writers from various news agencies, the swingers were Mormon couples, referring to members of the LDS Church. From this,
Hulu launched the reality television series
The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives in 2024. Following its debut, Paul was coined a "breakout star" and "the
MVP" of season 1 with Hansika Khokhar of
Collider writing: "Taylor’s presence was undeniable. She gave what needed to be given. She was raw, she was unpredictable, and she gave zero filtered responses. She managed to turn what could’ve been a short-lived TikTok infamy into long-form storytelling gold... And fans noticed. Reddit threads, TikTok recaps, Instagram lives dissecting every frame—Taylor was the center of it all. Whether you loved her, hated her, or fluctuated between the two within the same episode, she ended up winning Season 1." In June 2025, Paul was listed on
TIME Magazine's Top 100 Creators of 2025. In March 2026, Paul was scheduled to be the Bachelorette for its
22nd season and had completed filming. The season was cancelled by
ABC following reporting by
TMZ that released footage of a drunk Paul throwing chairs at Mortensen and accidentally hitting her daughter with one during the domestic violence incident in 2023. It was revealed that Paul had been investigated by law enforcement at least three times for domestic violence allegations in 2023 and 2024. Reportedly, the most recent domestic violence incident occurred in February 2026, resulting in a new police investigation being conducted against Paul and they ultimately declined to press charges; additionally, Mortensen sought and was granted temporary sole custody of their son by a judge. However, in early April 2026, the judge modified his order and granted Paul up to eight hours of supervised visits with her son per week with a follow up hearing set to occur on April 30th. As a result of the ongoing controversy, filming for
The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives was paused for a month before restarting without Paul or Mortensen. Paul deactivated her social media accounts on April 23. On April 30, 2026, Paul and Mortensen were ordered to stay 100 feet away from each other for the next three years; it was revealed that 11 fights between the pair were under review; In an unrelated revelation, it was disclosed that Paul had experienced several
miscarriages which influenced her behavior toward Mortensen. == References ==