After returning home from the war, Benning settled in
Neligh, Nebraska, where he entered the baking trade. He opened the Neligh Bakery (later marketed as "Benning's Bakery") in 1926, which he operated until his retirement in 1965. Benning was active in community affairs, including volunteering with the Masonic Lodge and
Veterans of Foreign Wars, serving as a member of the Antelope County Committee on Jurors, and serving as president of the Neligh Chamber of Commerce. In 1946, he helped organize fundraising activities for the Neligh Memorial Hospital fund. In 1940 Benning was elected commander of American Legion post No. 172, a role he held for seventeen years. Benning delivered speeches to
World War II draftees and assisted in home front efforts during the war. Despite registering for
the draft, he was not called to serve during the war.
Public service In 1945, Benning was appointed to the State of Nebraska Veterans Loan Certifying Committee. In April 1948, Benning was elected Mayor of Neligh with 66 percent of the vote, and sworn in on April 22, 1948. In 1949, Benning accidentally discharged a firearm and shot a city councilman. At the request of a night watchman, he was examining a .38 caliber revolver for defects, unaware that the gun was loaded after he had examined it a few minutes prior. The councilman received a minor wound in the finger, and was otherwise unharmed. Benning was reelected without opposition in 1950. Benning also served on the local Disaster Relief Committee which coordinated with the Red Cross to serve 1,200 families during snowbound emergencies in the severe winter storms of 1948. In 1950, Benning led the implementation of a new modern switchboard and phone system in the city. In 1951, he presided over the creation and establishment of Street Improvement Districts within the city. Benning did not seek reelection in 1952. Benning's time in office was referred to as a "turbulent period," with his main notable accomplishments being utility improvements, disaster relief, and a city-wide repaving project. In the 1950s and 1960s, Benning served on the local Retail Trade Committee and County Veterans Service Committee. In 1973 Benning was co-chair of the Neligh
centennial celebrations.
Freeman v. City of Neligh In 1952 the lawsuit
Freeman v. City of Neligh sought to prevent Benning and the city from proceeding with street improvement projects, arguing that the ordinance authorizing them was invalid due to procedural and constitutional issues. The
Nebraska Supreme Court ruled in favor of Benning and the city, upholding the ordinance and rejecting claims of improper procedure. ==Death==