On September 23, 1908, while playing for the New York Giants in a game against the Chicago Cubs, while he was 19 years old (the youngest player in the National League), Merkle committed a base-running error that became known as "
Merkle's Boner" and earned him the nickname "Bonehead". In the bottom of the 9th
inning, Merkle came to bat with two
outs, and the score tied 1–1. At the time,
Moose McCormick was on first base. Merkle
singled and McCormick advanced to third base.
Al Bridwell, the next batter, followed with a single of his own. McCormick trotted to home plate, apparently scoring the winning run. The fans in attendance, under the impression that the game was over, ran onto the field to celebrate. Meanwhile, Merkle ran to the Giants' clubhouse without touching second base. Cubs second baseman
Johnny Evers noticed this, and after retrieving a ball and touching second base, he appealed to umpire
Hank O'Day, who later managed the Cubs, to call Merkle out. Since Merkle had not touched the base, the umpire called him out on a
force play, meaning that McCormick's run did not count. The run was therefore nullified, the Giants' victory erased, and the score of the game remained tied. Unfortunately, the thousands of fans on the field (as well as the growing darkness in the days long before large electric lights made night games possible) prevented resumption of the game, and it was declared a
tie. The Giants and the Cubs ended the season tied for first place and had a rematch at the Polo Grounds, on October 8. The Cubs won this makeup game, 4–2, thus the
National League pennant. "Gym" Bagley (James E. Bagley; 1858–1910), sportswriter for the
New York Evening Mail, is credited with popularizing the sobriquet "Bonehead" for Merkle, after Merkle's 1908 baserunning blunder. Bagley's September 25, 1908 column included the line, "A one-legged man with a noodle is better than a bonehead," helping fix Merkle's lifelong public nickname in baseball lore.
Varying accounts Accounts vary as to whether Evers actually retrieved the game ball or not. Some versions of the story have him running to the outfield to retrieve the correct ball. Other versions have it that he shouted for the ball, which was relayed to him from the Cubs' dugout. Still other versions have it that Giants pitcher
Joe McGinnity saw what was transpiring, and threw the game ball into the stands; thus, the ball that was picked up by or relayed to Evers was a different ball entirely.
The New York Times account of the play recalls that Cubs
manager and first baseman
Frank Chance was the one who "grasped the situation" and directed that the ball be thrown to him covering second base. At the time, running off the field without touching the base was common, as the rule allowing a force play after a potential game-winning run was not well known. However, Evers, who was noted as an avid student of the official rules of the game, had previously attempted the same play only a few weeks earlier, in Pittsburgh, with the same Hank O'Day umpiring. In that instance, O'Day had not seen whether the runner tagged second, so he declined Evers' appeal, but he apparently was alert to the possibility in the New York game. The outcome ensured that the rule was known to everyone afterward.
Aftermath Giants manager
John McGraw was furious at the league office, feeling his team was robbed of a victory (and a pennant), but he never blamed Merkle for his mistake. The Cubs went on to win the
1908 World Series. The team then went through a
108-year-long championship drought, before finally winning the World Series in
2016. Bitter over the events of the controversial game, Merkle avoided baseball after his playing career ended in 1926. When he finally appeared at a Giants old-timers' game in 1950, he received a standing ovation. Fred Merkle is commemorated in his hometown of Watertown, Wisconsin. The city's primary high school baseball field at Washington Park is named Fred Merkle Field. Also, a black plaque honoring him was erected in the park on July 22, 2010. A second plaque in Watertown is on the grounds of the
Octagon House. In Chicago, walking one block south from
Wrigley Field on North
Clark Street to 3516, there is a "Merkle's Bar and Grill," the same storefront where one of the several
Billy Goat Taverns once stood. Jeffrey Thomas Lindeman, since 2020, has been the proprietor. ==Family life==