Upon Whitlow's return to
Jenner Park, Barry seen their goalscoring ace,
Dai Ward, retire from football – and as such, Whitlow had some mighty boots to fill. Linnets fans however need not have worried themselves. Whitlow was soon off the mark in an opening day defeat against
Cheltenham Town, and then earned Barry a point after getting a brace against
Bristol Rovers Reserves in a 2–2 draw. Whitlow's first hat-trick at Barry came in a Welsh League victory over rivals Llanelly. A further hat-trick ensued in the FA Cup 2nd Qualifying Round 7–0 thumping over Bristol Rose Green in October. He even scored 6 goals against a hapless Troedyrhiw on 9 November. It continued throughout the season, with Whitlow scoring 20 goals in 24 appearances in Southern League and Cup duties, and 27 goals in just 19 games in the Welsh League. With the Reserves of Exeter City playing in the Southern League at this point, it was inevitable that Whitlow would be pitted against his old side sooner or later. With the newspapers recognising Whitlow's prowess in Exeter colours, Barry trainer Charlie Green also hyped up his appearance against Exeter – stating that it would be appropriate for Whitlow to reach his half-century of goals for Barry against the Grecian XI. As it turned out, Whitlow didn't get onto the score-sheet, but as an Exeter player did head through his own net after pressure from Whitlow. No doubt Exeter knew what to expect from their former player! More plaudits came Whitlow's when his 2 goals in a 3–0 victory over
Swansea in the South Wales Senior Cup was described as being "a revelation for its quality to 5,000 spectators. It was a triumph of leadership on the part of Fred Whitlow, who got two of the goals, and presented the opportunity for half a dozen more." It was Barry's first Senior Cup victory in a decade. More successes came in the 1936–37 season, where Whitlow would score 22 Southern League and Cup goals in 21 appearances, and 27 goals in just 16 Welsh League appearances. Re-kindling his old Charlton Athletic and Exeter City hat-trick scoring exploits, Whitlow banged in 6 hat-tricks – equalling Dai Ward's record of a decade previously, and setting a bar that stood firm for a full 40 years until Clive Ayres scored 10 hat-tricks for Barry in the 1976–77 season. In total, Fred Whitlow's return to Barry had resulted in 100 goals in just two seasons. The 1936–37 season also saw Barry Town's greatest Welsh Cup exploits to that point. After a 3–1 deficit to Aberaman in the 5th Round was clawed back to a 4–3 victory by full-time, with a goal from Whitlow, a full strength Cardiff City were beaten at Jenner Park in the 6th Round in front of over 5,000 supporters. Whitlow even grabbed a goal in the famous 3–1 victory. Whitlow took a knock at Exeter in the following league match, which resulted in him missing the Welsh Cup Quarter-final victory over
Kidderminster Harriers. ==Retirement==