Whittingham accepted a scholarship from BYU, after it was the only
NCAA Division I school offer he received. He played
defensive end for the football team in 1957 and 1958. He was a part of the Tom Lee
boxing team, based on a recommendation he received to control his temper. He won the 1958 Intermountain Heavyweight Championship and the Regional Golden Gloves competition in
Las Vegas, receiving offers to turn professional. In 1959, he decided to transfer to
Cal Poly San Luis Obispo, before facing the possibility of being expelled after incurring violations in the school's conduct code. On October 29, 1960, he was in a hospital with a
concussion and didn't travel with his football team during the
Cal Poly football plane crash in
Toledo, Ohio, as the team was returning from a game against
Bowling Green State University. One of his surviving teammates was
Ted Tollner, who would also later become a football coach in the
NFL. He was a three-year starter for Cal Poly, playing
tight end and defensive end, while earning
Little All-America team honors in 1961. In his senior season he played
offensive guard, earning All-
California Collegiate Athletic Association (CCAA) honors. During his college career, he also competed in
track and field, finishing third in the
discus and the
shot put events in the 1961 CCAA Championships. In 2002, he was inducted into Cal Poly Athletics Hall of Fame. ==Professional career==