Trademark issues A notice of opposition was filed in federal court by FreecycleSunnyvale against the Freecycle Network in January 2006. An injunction was granted against Tim Oey in May 2006 for allegedly disparaging the TFN trademark. The injunction was stayed in July 2006 and dissolved by the
United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit in September 2007. To defend its trademark in 2006, TFN pursued other free recycling groups who used the word "freecycle" or allegedly had "confusingly similar derivations thereof". Free-speech advocates, including the
Electronic Frontier Foundation and 38 law professors, filed an
amicus brief opposing a trademark-infringement lawsuit filed by TFN against Tim Oey. The opposition was based on the position that the lawsuit violated Oey's
First Amendment rights. Other law professors, including
Lawrence Lessig, and
Jimmy Wales filed a second
amicus brief in support of Oey. In 2007, the US 9th Circuit Court affirmed that freecycle may be used as a word. On November 24, 2010, TFN lost its trademark claim to "Freecycle" and its logo in the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals. Justice
Consuelo María Callahan wrote in her opinion, "Beal did not coin the word 'freecycle' and TFN is not the first organization to promote freecycling ... even ... viewing the evidence in the light most favorable to TFN ... [they] engaged in naked licensing and consequently abandoned the trademarks." On September 25, 2012, TFN gained a registered trademark in the United States for Freecycle.org (registration number 4215094) from the
United States Patent and Trademark Office. TFN also received a registered-collective-membership trademark on that date (registration number 4215095). TFN maintains additional registered trademarks in the European Union, New Zealand, Australia and Canada.
UK breakaway During 2009, there were conflicts between the UK's independent association of TFN moderators and the organization's founders over the UK-based TFN groups' lack of freedom to develop local initiatives and features and their treatment of volunteer group owners and moderators. This resulted in the dismissal of at least 20 local group owners and moderators, who were replaced with new local TFN volunteers. Many owners of UK-based TFN groups formed a new independent association,
Freegle. TFN continued in the UK, with both groups present in many areas. In February 2015, TFN UK claimed to have 592 groups with 4,345,095 members.
Payment to Founder Based on the latest IRS 990s, the Freecycle founder receives an annual payment of £83,569 per year while the other listed officers are not compensated. Current 990 Forms (up to 2023) are available through a search of the IRS Tax Exempt Organization Search tool. ==See also==