The song was met with universal acclaim from
music critics, with strong praise for the composition. Jack Hamilton of
Slate categorized the song as the "most fun and exuberant track" on
Kids See Ghosts, labeling it heavily comparable to English musician
David Bowie's work because of the "booming walls of vocals, gnashing distortion, and thundering drums". Christopher R. Weingarten of
Rolling Stone expressed certainty in "Freeee (Ghost Town, Pt. 2)" being "fantastic", hailing it as "
gorgeously arranged" like tracks on West's fifth studio album
My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy (2010) "with a more spontaneous feel". Writing for
Entertainment Weekly, Chuck Arnold voiced a similar viewpoint; he remarked that the song "is the [same] type of wide-screen soundscape" as the album's tracks, while also stating there is "a liberating rush" from being able to feel "demons being kicked to the curb". Spencer Kornhaber from
The Atlantic commented how the song and "Ghost Town" are "a duo" that he considered to be the standout tracks of their respective albums, noticing the songs "roil with peeling guitar, off-key yowls, and drunken drumming". Kornhaber further praised the song for building on "a crunchy
funk-rock tune from [...] Mr. Chop", alongside highlighting Ty Dolla Sign's performance and West's vocals that differ from his.
NPR's Sidney Madden wrote Mr. Chop's sampled "soaring electric guitar riff" backs the "declarations of freedom" from West and Kid Cudi on "Freeee (Ghost Town, Pt. 2)" that "erupt into an all-out rebel yell", as well as commenting how the sample resembles "fuzzed-out
psychedelic rock of the
'70s". He continued, analyzing that the duo move forward "with a clear state of mind", and noticing their "childlike innocence and fearlessness".
Accolades NME ranked "Freeee (Ghost Town, Pt. 2)" as the 20th best song of 2018, with the publication's Dan Stubbs hailing it as a "standout track" from West's Wyoming Sessions. He further called the track "an empowering blast of booming vocals, thunderous drums" and West's "liberal shouts" of "
Scoop!", arguing that the use of the catchphrase may be West's "most admirable contribution to 2018's cultural melee". In July 2020,
Cool Accidents placed Ty Dolla Sign's appearance among his 11 best guest features. On October 25, 2018, it was reported that West's team had submitted the song for consideration in the categories of
Best Rock Song and
Best Rock Performance at the
61st Annual Grammy Awards. According to
TMZ, the song had already gone through the screening process for the categories at the time and "since been sent out on the first round ballot to voters", with the submissions awaiting enough support to be nominated. ==Commercial performance==