Reviewing the book in
Books+Publishing, Alan Vaarwerk said
From the Wreck has elements of history, science fiction and
magic realism, making it "utterly unique and distinctly Australian". He praised the author's "clear, lyrical prose" and the "breathtaking and revelatory reading experience" it creates. Ed Wright wrote in
The Australian that Rawson "stretch[es] our capacity to believe", making apparently incompatible ideas click together. He remarked that her empathy for the characters is "beautiful", particularly for the alien, who he compared to ET in
Spielberg's
1982 film. Wright felt that Rawson took a risk
anthropomorphising her alien: "it is a poor tool for imagining the inner lives of other beings", but he added, "it's one of the few we have, and Rawson has used it here to create an intriguing tale whose humanity lingers warm long after the reading." In a review in
The Canberra Times, Adam Rivett described
From the Wreck as "an old-fashioned historical yarn spliced with
Cronenbergian body horror". He pointed out that there are two narrative streams, "lyrical realism and the experimental", which quickly merge to produce "something truly unique and disquieting". Rivett said Rawson depicts the past as "both a recognisable Australia and ... an alien landscape". Writing in the Australian literary magazine,
Westerly, Christine Sun remarked that just as the alien tries to be human, the human becomes an alien by his inability to be "normal" anymore. She felt that the bond between Henry and the alien benefits both – they each get a new perspective on the world they are struggling to fit in to. Sun noted that by imagining what could have happened to Rawson's great-great-grandfather, she turned an apparently ordinary man's life into something extraordinary. Writing in the
Australian Book Review,
Fiona Wright called
From the Wreck "a deeply ecological novel", not quite
cli-fi, but one that emphasises "the connectedness of creatures: animal, human, and other worldly". She said the novel's "greatest strength" is George's characterisation, and described Rawson's handling of the trauma he experienced as "subtle and skilful". Wright also called Henry "a delightful and fascinating character". She did, however, feel that the voice of the shapeshifter, while "lyrical and fittingly alien", sometimes comes across as "overdetermined", which tends to "lose ... its novelty" after a while. She also criticised the novel's structure, saying that the purpose of some parts of the narrative are not clear, particularly some of the secondary characters, whose stories appear incomplete. But overall, Wright called it is "an ambitious novel" the way it "bend[s] and blend[s] genres". ==Awards==