In the
Oxford Dictionary of Word Origins, the term
fudge, used as an expression of annoyance, is traced to the 18th century. This use is described as likely stemming from the earlier "fadge", meaning "to fit". The creation of fudge in America is typically characterized as accidental, coming about as a cook attempted to make a different confection. Food writer Lee Edwards Benning, drawing on her experimentation with fudge describes the creation as most likely the outcome of "taking the ingredients for caramel and handling them as if making a fondant". Within Britain, various communities in the
Midlands and
Cornwall had been making local variations of the
Scottish sweet,
tablet, for centuries which would retroactively be referred to as fudge by the
1890s. Cornish fudge in particular traces its origins to the
18th century, when Cornish confectioners started using
clotted cream instead of milk to make their traditional version of tablet. "Chocolate caramels"—confections made by boiling milk, brown sugar, chocolate, and butter—were popular in the United States during the 1860s and 1870s. These had ingredient ratios and technique close to the modern fudge, and are characterised as a type of fudge by food writer
Stella Parks. One of these recipes cited by Parks was published in 1874 in the American agricultural magazine
The Cultivator and Country Gentleman, crediting a "Baltimore friend" for "Caramel": Unlike modern fudge, this fudge was stirred consistently, producing a crumbly texture as the syrup crystallized. Another similar recipe appeared in the
The Cultivator and Country Gentleman at the end of the decade, again drawing an association with Baltimore. When this confection began to be called fudge is difficult to identify, given the widespread use of 'fudge' in the colloquial sense during the 19th century. By the 1880s and 1890s, mentions of and recipes for fudge appeared widely in American periodicals and advertisements, arriving as prices for sugar and chocolate became increasingly cheap. This early fudge was cut into squares and diamonds and was marketed as a chaste, wholesome treat, contrasting with perceptions of contemporary confections such as luxury
bonbons and penny candy. Other than chocolate, early fudge were often flavored with butterscotch, coconut, maple sugar, and vanilla. The process by which fudge went from crumbly to smooth confection is likewise not firmly known, though Parks posits that the transition can be explained as a consequence of "sheer neglect", as fudge was left to cook over lower temperatures without stirring and the sugar crystals did not crystallize.
Fudge at women's colleges Making fudge was a popular activity at
women's colleges, especially
Vassar College in
Poughkeepsie, New York. In a letter written by Emelyn Battersby Hartridge, a student at
Vassar College, she recounts the purchase of a box of fudge, which was sold for 40 cents a pound in 1886 in
Baltimore, Maryland. She also claimed to have given fudge its “real introduction” to Vassar College in 1888 by selling her own batch. The diary of student Elma Martin mentions making "fudges" in 1892. An 1893 letter from a
Vassar College student Adelaide Mansfield describes "fudges" as containing sugar, fruit, chocolate, milk, and butter. A recipe for "Fudges at Vassar" was printed in
The Sun in 1894. Despite describing the confections as "Vassar chocolates", the recipe given comprises sugar, milk, butter, and vanilla extract.
Wellesley College and
Smith College have their own versions of a fudge recipe dating from the late 19th or early 20th century. The popularity of fudge on women's college campuses was expressed in an 1895 song by Vassar students: By the 1920s fudge was being eaten in the United Kingdom under its American name and as "tablets", as evidenced by its appearance in the 1920 edition of ''
Harmsworth's Universal Encyclopaedia'', which described fudge as "a sweetmeat that hails from America, but is now popular in other countries also. [It is] made from white or brown sugar, milk, cream, or condensed milk, butter and flavored with chocolate, coffee, and vanilla essence. Margarine can be used instead of butter, but the toffee does not set so well nor is the taste quite so rich or good". == Ingredients ==