The Washington Post wrote that "the Louisville quartet employs a bluesy groove on songs like 'Dirty City Rainy Day' and plunges into the Delta with the honking 'Bad Cat Blues', but its sauntering rhythms, zany lyrics and boy-girl vocals more often recall the B-52's than Muddy Waters."
Trouser Press thought that, "with its herky-jerky rhythms and kitschy organ flourishes ...
Funny Farm bears more than a passing resemblance to the B-52’s’ early days—an analogy furthered by the decidedly Cindy Wilsonized vocal harmonies Amy George drizzles over 'Island Paradise' and the frankly touching 'Dirty City, Rainy Day'." The
Wisconsin State Journal labeled the album "oddly Jonathan Richman-esque pop."
Spin deemed
Funny Farm "the compost-rock party record of the summer," writing that "the concept is Southern soul with all the archivism purged away, all the metaphorical presence reduced to a sneer, and all the sing-songy party hooks mixed loud." The
Chicago Tribune praised the "sparse, casually goofball lyrics spread over chattering funk guitar, danceable bass lines and cheesy organ." The
Chicago Reader determined that
Funny Farm "brings to mind Dr. Seuss and Calvin Johnson collaborating on a musical version of Orwell's
Animal Farm."
AllMusic wrote that "the arrangements are fun and playful, as organs and synths creep in among neatly crafted guitar lines and witty lyrics, making for an incredibly live texture—very fitting for a record with such a lack of seriousness." ==Track listing==