After Archer's grave was discovered in 2015, some of the archaeologists who had found it came up with a theory that Archer was secretly a
Catholic, based on the manner of his burial. Archer's parents were at some point fined for not attending Anglican services because they were Catholic. Archer had also attended Cambridge, which was known at that time, according to James Horn of the Jamestown Rediscovery Project, to be a university with some Catholic presence. The piece of evidence that initially started the theory that Gabriel Archer was a Catholic, however, was a small silver box that was buried next to him. It is believed to be a Catholic
reliquary that contains fragments of bones and a lead
ampulla. Horn reports that the box was probably intentionally placed in the grave with him, presumably by one of Archer's fellow Catholics. However, the reliquary is not necessarily conclusive evidence, because at this time the
Church of England was still shifting away from Catholic symbolism and Catholic practices were being repurposed for Anglican use. If Archer were a Catholic, James Horn and others have mentioned that that could provide a reason for his animosity with some of the top colonial leaders. Before this, some
rosaries and
crucifixes had been found at Jamestown, but there was no evidence that they came from Catholic settlers specifically. After disturbing Archer’s remains and the relics meant to accompany them in eternity, Historic Jamestowne has not reinstated the tomb and provides no explanation for this desecration. == References ==