Batton has faced pressure from some in the U.S. Congress over the tribe's refusal to extend citizenship to
freedmen, to the point where
Maxine Waters (D-CA) threatened to withhold housing funds unless the tribe relented. The tribe currently excludes freedmen under the rule that they are not "Choctaw by-blood", as defined in the 1983 Constitution. Ultimately, the congressional threat went nowhere. Batton insists that refusing citizenship to the freedmen is "not a race issue", and was joined by Dr. Carter Blue Clark, a
Muscogee Nation citizen and a professor of Indigenous Law at
Oklahoma City University, in claiming it is an issue of tribal sovereignty, and no business of the federal government. Although a registered
Republican, Batton joined his fellow chiefs of the
Five Tribes to endorse Democrat
Joy Hofmeister for governor against incumbent Republican
Kevin Stitt in
2022. His decision was reportedly criticized by some in the tribal council, as the tribes had remained neutral to this point and never endorsed state-wide candidates before. Although the Choctaw Constitution explicitly outlaws same-sex marriage, in May 2023, the Choctaw Constitutional Court ruled that tribal members have a right to marry, regardless of gender. The court claimed the tribal constitution was restricting the rights of tribal citizens, which are guaranteed to them under federal law via the
14th Amendment. After the ruling, Batton took no steps to challenge the court, instead stating "we offer our love and support to the family involved in this case." ==Personal life==