1956 NFL draft In 1956, the
Pittsburgh Steelers had won the first overall pick by way of bonus pick determined by lottery, and they also had the fifth pick in the first round. The Steelers used the bonus pick to make Glick the first overall selection in the draft. Glick's selection was viewed by many as a surprise, and Glick himself was surprised. It was reported in the Pittsburgh media at the time of the draft that all of the Steelers first four draft choices, who included Glick, were "personally scouted by members of the Steeler staff" before their selection. Nearly a year later, it was reported that Keisling had selected Glick "sight unseen" and one "who came highly recommended to the Steelers by Western observers".
Dan M. Rooney, the son of then Steelers' owner
Art Rooney and a Steelers' executive (and future owner) later said that he had wanted the team to draft quarterback Earl Morrall, but the team was concerned about its weak defensive secondary. Rooney said the Steelers did not scout Glick, which was not uncommon in the 1950s. Rather the team would look at records and newspaper articles, and then contact a player's coach. In Glick's case, the Steelers did a little film study and talked to Bob Davis. Davis had coached a number of good defensive players over the years, and told the Steelers Glick was the best defensive player he had ever coached. Rooney reported that Davis had written a series of letters to Kiesling encouraging the Steelers to select Glick in the draft saying, among other things, "Never in my entire coaching career was I as high on a player as I am on Gary. He simply can’t miss in the pro league". Among the players drafted later in the 1956 draft were future Hall of Fame legends such as
Lenny Moore (1st round, 9th pick),
Forrest Gregg (2nd round, 20th pick) and
Sam Huff (3rd round, 30th pick). At the time, the question was why the Steelers chose Glick over No. 2 pick quarterback Morrall and No. 3 pick running back
Howard "Hopalong" Cassady; which Kiesling addressed by identifying players the Steelers already had that he believed could do the job at those positions (including
Jim Finks at quarterback). During his rookie season (1956), the 26-year old Glick was a two-way player and kicker for the Steelers. He played receiver, running back, linebacker, cornerback and safety that season; but was chiefly a kicker and defensive back. He started eight games in 1956 (in a 12-game season), making four field goals in seven attempts. He also made 16 extra points in 17 attempts. Glick also recovered two fumbles. The Steelers finished the 1956 season 5–7, and Kiesling was replaced before the 1957 season by
Buddy Parker as head coach. Ironically, before the 1957 season started, the Steelers traded linebacker
Marv Matuszak and their 1958 and 1959 first round draft picks to the
San Francisco 49ers for Morrall, because Parker believed the team desperately needed a quarterback. In 1957, Glick started nine games. Glick was 5–of–18 in his second and final year kicking field goals, and made 10 extra points in 12 attempts. He was a reserve defensive back with the Steelers through two games of the 1959 season. At the end of September, Glick was traded to the
Washington Redskins for a high draft choice. In four years with the Steelers, Glick started 29 games, with four interceptions and 10 fumble recoveries. In 1960, he started three games, with three interceptions and a fumble recovery for a touchdown against the
St. Louis Cardinals in a November game. Washington waived Glick in 1961, and a few days later he signed with the
Baltimore Colts for the 1961 season. He started eight games with the Colts, playing right cornerback. He had a career-high four interceptions in his one season with the club, with three occurring in a game against Washington on November 26, setting a team record. who would visit Glick's home over the years. but he was added to the Chargers roster at the end of October. He started three games for the Chargers at safety. He faced his brother Fred's
Houston Oilers on December 1 and 15, the Chargers winning both games. Glick recorded the final interception of his career against Houston on December 1. Over a month later, the Chargers won the
AFL Championship Game, with Glick retiring a winner in his final game. He was the starting free safety in that championship game. == Coaching and scouting career ==