Minor leagues After high school, the
Milwaukee Brewers drafted Sheffield with the sixth pick of the first round of the
1986 MLB draft. Sheffield later said that if he had not been drafted in the first round, he probably would have played
college baseball for the
Miami Hurricanes. After being drafted he played for the
Helena Brewers of the
Pioneer League, where he had a .365
batting average and 71 RBIs in 57 games. The only question was what
position he would play. He was slotted at shortstop, but struggled at the position, committing many
errors and wild throws. In 1987, he was assigned to
Stockton of the
Class-A California League, where his defense improved and he produced at the plate. His batting average went below .300, but he led the league in RBIs with 103, and at the end of the year he was voted the Brewers' best prospect. In his third season, he went from Double-A to the majors. In 134 games for the
El Paso Diablos and
Denver Zephyrs, he batted .327 with 28 homers and 118 RBIs.
Milwaukee Brewers in 1988 Sheffield was called up from the minors when rosters were expanded in September and made his major league debut on September 3, 1988. Still a teenager, he got off to a fast start, with his first career hit being a home run off
Mark Langston, though Sheffield finished the season with a .238 batting average and four home runs in 24 games. After mediocre play and injuries that forced him to miss two months in the summer of 1989, Sheffield was moved to third base, replaced by
Bill Spiers at shortstop. Sheffield said he was shocked by the move and criticized the team. He also said his race affected the reception from other players, management, and fans in Milwaukee. In his rookie season, he batted .247 with five home runs and 32 RBIs. In 1990, he worked under
Don Baylor, who had been hired as their
hitting coach. He finished the season batting .294, with 10 home runs. In his final season with the Brewers, he injured his wrist, thumb, and shoulder, playing in only 50 games. He never regularly played in the infield for the rest of his career. He was traded to the
Los Angeles Dodgers in 1998 because the Marlins allegedly could not afford a contract extension and because the Dodgers' parent company at the time,
News Corporation, was looking to secure a television contract with the Marlins in exchange for trading popular Dodger
Mike Piazza. He joined a lineup that included
Derek Jeter,
Jason Giambi and the newly acquired
Alex Rodriguez. In his first season with the Yankees, Sheffield started slowly but finished the season with 36 home runs, 121 RBIs, and a .290 batting average, finishing second in the
MVP voting behind
Vladimir Guerrero. On July 27, Sheffield hit his 400th career home run off of
Micheal Nakamura of the
Toronto Blue Jays. In his second season with the Yankees, he continued to play well, hitting another 34 home runs and driving in 123 runs. On April 14, 2005, a
Red Sox fan leaned over the railing at
Fenway Park and distracted Sheffield as he was going to field a ball hit by
Jason Varitek. After Sheffield took a swing at the fan with his glove, he threw the ball back into the infield, and then got into a verbal altercation with the fan. Fan interference was not called, resulting in a game-tying RBI triple for Varitek. The fan, a long-time season ticket holder, was not ejected from Fenway Park, but he donated his remaining 2005
season tickets to charity in an effort to avoid any controversy for the remainder of the season. Sheffield was fined for the incident. Charges were dismissed against both the fan and Sheffield. Sheffield started the 2006 season on pace for a .300 batting average and 30 homers before he collided with
Shea Hillenbrand of the
Toronto Blue Jays on April 29. Sheffield tried to play despite the injury, but ultimately needed wrist surgery. Sheffield did not return until late September. He had lost his right field job to
Bobby Abreu, whom the Yankees had acquired in a trade deadline transaction. This forced Sheffield to play first base for the first time in his MLB career. During a July 2007 interview with
HBO's
Real Sports, Sheffield said that Yankees manager
Joe Torre treated black players differently from white players during his time there, citing himself,
Kenny Lofton and
Tony Womack as examples. Lofton later agreed with Sheffield's comments about being treated differently, but disagreed that race was the motivating factor. After it was pointed out that Derek Jeter is
biracial, Sheffield responded that he wasn't "all the way black."
Detroit Tigers On November 10, 2006, the Yankees traded Sheffield to the
Detroit Tigers for minor league pitchers
Humberto Sánchez,
Kevin Whelan, and
Anthony Claggett. After the trade, Sheffield agreed to a two-year, $28 million extension. In his first season with the Tigers, he hit 25 home runs with 75 RBIs and a .265 batting average. Sheffield also hit his first triple since 2004 and stole 20 bases for the first time since 1990. He was also one of six batters in the
AL with least 20 home runs and 20
stolen bases, along with
Alex Rodriguez,
Grady Sizemore,
Ian Kinsler,
B. J. Upton and teammate at the time
Curtis Granderson. On September 8, in a game against
Oakland, Sheffield hit the 250,000th regular season home run in MLB history according to
Baseball-Reference.com. The home run was a
grand slam off
Gio González; Sheffield had hit baseball's 249,999th home run against Gonzalez in his previous at bat. Sheffield ended the 2008 season with 499 career home runs. On September 19, 2008, Sheffield was hit by a pitch from
Cleveland Indians pitcher
Roberto Hernández (then using the name Fausto Carmona) and walked to first base. When Hernández threw to first base, he and Sheffield exchanged words and Sheffield charged the mound, attempting to tackle Hernández but being caught in a headlock and punched a few times on the top of his head by the pitcher, leading to a
bench-clearing brawl. Hernández and Sheffield were both ejected, along with Indians catcher
Víctor Martínez and Tigers second baseman
Plácido Polanco. On September 22, the commissioner's office announced four suspensions resulting from the brawl: Hernández was suspended for six games, Sheffield received a four-game suspension, and Martinez and Indians infielder
Asdrúbal Cabrera each received three-game suspensions. Sheffield said after the suspension that the involved players from the Indians would be "penalized" by him as well. On March 31, 2009, the Tigers released Sheffield despite owing him $14 million. Tigers general manager
Dave Dombrowski said the team wanted to have more versatility at designated hitter.
New York Mets On April 3, 2009 Sheffield agreed to sign with the
New York Mets. On April 17, Sheffield hit
his 500th home run, becoming the 25th player in MLB history to reach that milestone, the first player to achieve this as a pinch-hitter, and the first to do so with the Mets. Sheffield was the third player in major league history to hit a home run before age 20 and after age 40, joining
Ty Cobb and
Rusty Staub.
Alex Rodriguez became the fourth player to do so in 2015. Sheffield sat out a game in August when the Mets declined to offer him a contract extension.
Retirement Sheffield did not play in 2010. Though he initially suggested he wanted to sign with a team for the 2011 season, he announced his retirement at the beginning of 2011
spring training. ==Career highlights==