Gay Hermit was retired to stand stud at
Haras Ojo de Agua after his injury. Gay Hermit led the Argentine general sire list four times, in 1896, 1897, 1898, and 1901. He led the Argentine broodmare sire list six times, 1910–1913, 1915, and 1916, and finished second in 1918 and third in 1914.
Notable progeny • Cordon Rouge, winner of the
Gran Premio Nacional,
Gran Premio Jockey Club,
Clásico Eliseo Ramírez,
Clásico Ignacio Correas, etc. • Valero, winner of the Gran Premio Nacional and Gran Premio Jockey Club • Balcarce, winner of the
Gran Premio Polla de Potrillos • Berezina, winner of the
Gran Premio Polla de Potrancas • Celso, winner of La Copa, champion sire in Chile • Citoyenne, winner of the Gran Premio Polla de Potrancas • Colombia, winner of the
Gran Premio Selección • Espina, winner of the Gran Premio Selección • Fedra, winner of the Gran Premio Polla de Potrancas • Gonin, champion sire in Chile • Talma, winner of the Gran Premio Polla de Potrillos and
Durban July Handicap • Tarantula, winner of the Gran Premio Selección • Túnica, winner of the
Clásico St. Leger, etc.
Notable progeny of daughters • Locandiera, winner of the
Gran Premio Selección and
Gran Premio Polla de Potrancas • Parva, winner of the Gran Premio Selección,
Premio Ignacio Correas, etc. • Partícula, winner of the Gran Premio Selección • Elcano, winner of the
Clásico General San Martín • Enero, winner of the
Clásico Comparación • Magda, winner of the Polla de Potrancas (Chile) and
Clásico St. Leger ==Sire line tree==