After the group Smith disbanded, Gayle McCormick recorded three solo albums. Many of her songs were penned by
Dennis Lambert and Brian Potter, who also produced
Gayle McCormick, her debut album of mostly covers. This platter was released in 1971 on ABC Dunhill, the same label as the contemporary sensation
Three Dog Night. To support this record, McCormick took her touring group, billed as the Underhand Band, on the road across North America. McCormick's outfit opened for Three Dog Night. McCormick confessed that she intentionally shed her 'Smith' image (even though her new band routinely performed "Baby It's You"). She stated that she felt more confident as a solo artist, being able to choose her own material. "I pick songs that I can feel and put myself into," McCormick told a Cincinnati Enquirer reporter. While she did not envision herself singing professionally in another twenty years, she was enjoying herself on the road. On the radio, McCormick's performance of Lambert and Potter's "It's a Cryin' Shame" charted at a modest #44 on the
Billboard Hot 100 but later became a top 10 hit on the new
Adult Contemporary chart. It was covered in 1976 by
Cher. McCormick also recorded an
American Bandstand video for "It's a Cryin' Shame." Her follow-up single, "You Really Got a Hold on Me," barely scraped the
Billboard Hot 100 at #98. Another single, "C'est La Vie," failed to generate any chart activity. McCormick recorded a version of "Superstar" at around the same time as
the Carpenters recorded their major hit. McCormick admitted her first album was something of a "downer...Most of the songs, well, just weren't my kind of material," she said. "But I did it because it was a single album and...I needed that. Now, I know what I want to do." She hinted that her next releases would move away from the "bubble-gum" of her first single and fully embrace the R&B style she greatly preferred. McCormick recorded her second album on a new label, Decca/MCA at
Bolic Sound Studios in early 1972. However, McCormick continued to work with manager Burt Jacobs, the same manager as Three Dog Night.
Flesh & Blood, McCormick's new package of R&B-influenced tunes, was perhaps her strongest offering, with generally positive reviews in the U.S. and Canada. It was co-produced by Tom Thacker and Joe Schermie, former bassist for Three Dog Night. The LP cover featured McCormick in tight cutoffs and a form-fitting top, capitalizing on the chiefly male appeal she was receiving at this time. McCormick co-wrote "Take Me Back," the opening track on
Flesh & Blood, and she had more creative control over her material. Frank Collette of the Underhand Band recorded most of the keyboards, with contributions from Gary Stephens and Eddie Beyer. Stan Seymore played guitar, Maurice Miller handled the drums, and Ray Neapolitan served as bassist. In addition, the multi-instrumentalist Don Menza played and arranged the "McCormick Horns" section with
Chuck Findley (trumpet and trombone), Slyde Hyde (additional trombones), and Sam Falzone (tenor saxophone). McCormick toured with her nine-piece band in support of
Flesh & Blood, including several dates on the California night-club circuit. Despite Decca's efforts to rebrand McCormick, neither single from her second album, the ballad "Near You" nor the rock-inflected "Grey Line Tour," charted. More than one reviewer from this period lamented the fact that McCormick possessed great vocal talent, but could not find a radio hit. After two big commercial disappointments in the top 40 arena, McCormick changed music labels once again in 1973, this time to Fantasy Records. She continued to tour sporadically, sharing one date with the ascendant
Stevie Wonder in El Paso. Ultimately, McCormick drifted toward the
Easy Listening and
Country and Western spheres, releasing the album
One More Hour on Fantasy in 1974. Reviews were sparse in comparison with her earlier music, but still somewhat favorable. Like its predecessor, "Hour" failed to chart despite a spirited cover of "Original Midnight Mama," which echoed her first love of R&B music. For her final efforts at Top 40 airplay, McCormick recorded two
dance-rock tracks, "Coming in Out of the Rain" and "Simon Said," for a 1975 45 single on the Shady Brook label. McCormick also contributed backing vocals to Jimmy Rabbitt and Renegade's
Waylon Jennings-produced 1976 self-titled Capitol LP, from which the single "Ladies Love Outlaws" was drawn. At this time, she covered "Torn Between Two Lovers," first made popular by
Mary MacGregor. ==Personal life==