St. Clair directed
Louise Brooks in two films for Paramount before pre-production began on
Gentlemen Prefer Blondes, each satiric comedies released in 1926:
A Social Celebrity and
The Show-Off. In both films she played the leading female protagonist. Brooks would also star in
The Canary Murder Case (1929), also directed by St. Clair and her final film with Paramount. Film historian Ruth Anne Dwyer, in her biography of Malcolm St. Clair, examines the circumstances concerning the casting for the lead role of Dorothy Shaw for the 1929 version of
Gentlemen Prefer Blondes (note:
Jane Russell was cast as Dorothy in the
1953 remake of the film directed by
Howard Hawks). The Anita Loos novel
Gentleman Prefer Blondes (1925) inspired at least three popular spin-offs: • A 1926 film entitled
Just Another Blonde, directed by
Alfred Santell for
First National Pictures. •
Show Girl, a magazine serial created by
J. P. McEvoy, featuring a character named Dixie Dugan, modeled on Dorothy Shaw. • A cartoon strip entitled
Dixie Dugan by
John H. Striebel, with Dixie also a “Dorothy-like” figure. Dwyer reports Dixie Dugan, “a cynical
flapper,” were “thinly disguised” tributes to the actress Louise Brooks. In the Santell production for
Just Another Blonde, Brooks was cast as a “gold-digging show girl" similar to the fictional Dorothy Shaw. When First National made a film adaption of the magazine Show Girl in 1927, clearly based on Brooks’ screen persona in
Just Another Blonde,
Alice White was selected to play the role: Brooks, who expected to be cast, was not offered a screen test, though, according to her biographer
Barry Paris she was “made" for the part. Brooks’ in anticipation of securing the role, posed for a photo depicting her reading a copy of Loos’ novel. Both director Malcolm St. Clair and novelist Anita Loos screen-tested actors for the role of Dorothy Shaw in
Gentlemen Prefer Blondes, including Louise Brooks, but settled on Antia White. According to Dwyer, Paris describes a bitterly disappointed Brooks, who subsequently denounced St. Clair as a drunkard and his direction of Paramount production of the film as a failure. Film critic Beth Ann Gallagher reports that contemporary reviews of the film were “lukewarm,” and that the cast was ranked among critics higher than the production. Dwyer notes that the movie was “quite a success” with
New York Times critic
Mordaunt Hall, who described it as “splendid” and Alice White “an excellent selection” to perform the character Dorothy Shaw. Dwyer reports that St. Clair's professional and personal contemporaries she interviewed contradict and correct Brooks’ negative appraisal of the director. ==Reception==