For ten weeks in 1999, she was a member of Chicago-based
stage combat theatre company
Babes With Blades. As part of that role, she performed a scene from
Robin Hood: Prince of Thieves,
The Miracle Worker and
Heathers. She also appeared as part of the cast in the North American tour of
Wicked alongside
Adam Lambert, whom she later supported when he appeared on
American Idol. She credits
Rosie O'Donnell with getting her first
Broadway role alongside
Boy George in
Taboo. Rosie later described her as "fresh off a
Disney Cruise", but allowed her to come back for a second attempt. Elliott spent $117 to change her outfit and make-up in order to be better suited to the role; O'Donnell reimbursed Elliott when she was awarded a part in the show. The show closed after only a hundred performances, but O'Donnell subsequently praised Elliott's passion for the show. Elliott went on to play Majella in
The Pirate Queen, which opened in Chicago in 2006 and moved to Broadway in 2007. Her first film role was in the
Mel Gibson film
What Women Want in 2000. In 2009, Elliott was cast as main character Jane Bingum on
Lifetime's
Drop Dead Diva. After the pilot,
The New York Times described Elliott as "convincing, and even affecting, at every turn", and the
Los Angeles Times said she was "a stage actress with fabulous comic timing and enormous dramatic flexibility". The show ended after its
sixth season in 2014. In 2016, Elliott starred opposite
Katey Sagal in the CBS comedy pilot
Upper Middle Bogan inspired by the Australian series. It was not ordered to series. In 2018, she went to star in the ABC comedy pilot created by Bobby Bowman about a dysfunctional family struggling with mental illness. In 2019, Elliot was cast in a leading role on the Netflix romantic drama series
Sweet Magnolias. In 2022, she executive produced and starred as a country music superstar in the Lifetime holiday movie
A Country Christmas Harmony. ==Personal life==