Bout with Jeff Smith, future Australian World Middleweight Champion On December 7, 1915, Chip lost to Jeff Smith, future Australian World Middleweight Champion, in a seventh round disqualification at the Hippodrome in Boston. The
New Castle News wrote that Chip was clearly winning the contest when he was disqualified by the referee for a low blow. Some reporters wrote the blow to the torso was not below the belt, and believed Chip was close to winning the bout by knockout.
Bouts with Jimmy Clabby Between November 1914 and May 1915, Chip fought
Jimmy Clabby four times. Clabby, an exceptional talent, competed for but never won a world title in his career, though he took the World Middleweight and Light Heavyweight titles of Australia and the Heavyweight Championship of New Zealand. On November 6, 1914, Chip lost a twenty-round bout with Clabby in
Daly City, California, outside San Francisco. The
San Francisco Chronicle reported that Clabby won easily, taking seventeen rounds.
Competing for the Australian World Middleweight Championship On September 30, 1916, Chip fell to a ninth-round knockout from Australian boxer
Les Darcy for Australia's World Middleweight Title in Sydney. The Australian fans bet heavily on their national champion, who carried the fight decisively throughout. He followed on November 6, 1916, with an important fourteenth-round knockout victory over American boxer Art Magirl in Melbourne.
Bouts with Middleweight Champions Harry Greb and Mike Gibbons Chip fought the great middleweight
Harry Greb four times in his career, losing decisively to Greb on November 19, 1917, in a ten-round bout in Cincinnati, Ohio. On May 22, 1917, Greb beat Chip in an exciting ten round bout before a crowd of 4,000 in Pittsburgh. In two earlier fights in Pennsylvania, Chip beat Greb according to newspapers on June 26, 1916, but received a draw earlier in a closer fight in Pittsburgh in 1915.
Impressive win over Harry Greb In their ten-round no decision bout on June 26, 1916, in New Castle, Pennsylvania, local newspapers agreed that Chip had the decisive edge over Greb in an impressive win. The
New Castle Herald gave Chip every round, and the
Post gave Greb only three rounds.
Bouts with brothers Mike and Tommy Gibbons In the July 1917 bout between Chip and Gibbons at Wright Field in
Youngstown, Ohio, Gibbon's World Middleweight Title was at stake if he lost by knockout. The
Washington Post wrote that "Gibbons won all the way". In their slow January, 1919 bout in Duluth, Gibbons defeated Chip by a "wide margin" after returning from fifteen months in the Army. In a faster bout before a substantial crowd in
Terre Haute, Indiana, on June 11, 1919, Chip landed several strong blows but they never fazed Gibbons who had the edge in their fight according to newspapers. Chip also fought Gibbons' brother Tommy Gibbons five times from 1917 to 1919 though he never beat him in the opinion of most newspapers. ==Retirement from boxing==