Critic
Dorothy Parker described the play in a November 1921 theater review column for ''
Ainslee's Magazine: "There is little use in retelling the plot of Getting Gertie's Garter'', even if one could keep track of it. The title is, in itself, a complete scenario. The quest for the garter includes several badly confused sets of married couples, a comedy butler, a French maid, and a generous assortment of lines at which large ladies in the audience laugh hysterically and nudge their companions viciously. It is a curious thing that the Messrs. Collison and Hopwood will go as far as it is humanly possible, with the limits of the English language, to get a questionable line, but that they will permit no mention of the human leg, nor of the accouterments worn thereon. They do not even allow themselves the use of the word 'limb', preferring some much more circuitous reference, while the garter is described as 'something a girl must use to keep up her -- er -- appearances.' What do you make of this, my dear
Freud?... It is discouraging to report that, despite the heroic work of its cast and the labor of its authors, ''Getting Gertie's Garter'' remains far less depraved than those who have its success at heart could wish." ==Adaptations==