"Getting No Sleep" received positive notices from critics. Kiana Mickles from
Resident Advisor highlighted
Nosaj Thing's "introspective downtempo" production, noting that it gives the track "a similarly melancholic bounce". Kyann-Sian Williams of
NME likewise praised the track. He described it as an understated
electro-pop moment that returns to her escapist sensibilities. Williams also called the song "a sleek ode to nocturnal escapades".
Varietys Thania Garcia also wrote that "Getting No Sleep" arrived with a stylized,
Mad Max-themed visual that allows both the song's provocative lyrics — "How does it feel to be fuckin' with me?" — and Tinashe's "buttery vocals" to take focus.
HotNewHipHop writer Elias Andrews added that rather than doubling down on the aggression of "Nasty", Tinashe instead pivots into "a more chill direction". Andrews characterized "Getting No Sleep" as a "slower, subtler
sequel", and emphasized that this shift "isn't a bad thing". Additionally,
Slant Magazines Nick Seip observed that "Getting No Sleep" is "effortlessly cool" in its low-key presentation. The song earned recognition in
Uproxxs weekly roundup, All The Best New Pop Music, on July 2, 2024. ==Track listing==