"Girl Don't Come" gave Shaw a No. 2 hit in South Africa and in Canada. In Australia, the song reached No. 48. Like "(There's) Always Something There to Remind Me", "Girl Don't Come" became a regional hit in the United States – where it was released in February 1965 – without entering the
Top 40, although it peaked at No. 42 on the
Billboard Hot 100 the week of April 23, 1965. It fared slightly better on the
Cash Box Top 100, peaking at No. 35 the week of April 3, 1965. Shaw was unable to do U.S. promotion – including a
Shindig! appearance scheduled for March – due to the U.S. Federation of TV and Radio Artists refusing her an American work permit. It would be her biggest chart hit in the U.S.A. Shaw made a belated Italian rendition of "Girl Don't Come" entitled "E ti avrò" in 1966 and, aided by her performance of it on
Studio Uno, the top variety show in Italy, "E ti avrò" became a No. 11 hit in 1966–67 (the single's B-side: "Viva l’amore con te" was a version of Shaw's UK No. 1 hit "
Long Live Love"). Also in 1966, Shaw's Spanish-language version of "Girl Don't Come" entitled "No vendrá" was released on an
EP in Spain, which also included Spanish versions of her hits "Tomorrow", "Long Live Love" and "Message Understood".
Lill Lindfors recorded a
Swedish version entitled "Ingen kom" for her 1967 album
Du är den ende. ==In popular culture==