Cash Box said that "mighty guitar riffs explode on impact" and the song has "a touch of the
Badfinger sound."
Record World said that "its effective combination of
hard rock and top 40 stylings make this a natural for playlists of virtually every [radio] format."
Wichita Beacon critic Paul Baker compared the song's guitar riff to that of
Free's "
All Right Now." Swanson rated it as the Raspberries' greatest song and "the definitive
power pop song of all time."
Classic Rock History critic Brian Kachejian concurred, praising the melody and arrangement and calling it "an iconic pop gem." Kachejian also noted that "The way the verse transcends into the song's chorus riding on the wings of Eric Carmen's legendary lead vocal is one for the ages." Steve Sullivan wrote in the
Encyclopedia of Great Popular Song Recordings that the opening guitar riff is one of the best in rock, saying that it "still has the capacity to startle and thrill more than four decades later." The tune ranked at number 33 on the
Billboard Year-End Top 100 of 1972 and number 39 on
Cashboxs year-end best-sellers countdown. In 1989,
Spin magazine named "Go All the Way" in its list of the "100 Greatest Singles of All Time", ranking it at number 91. "Go All the Way" appeared in
Blender magazine's July 2006 issue as one of its "Greatest Songs Ever". ==Live performances==