Critical response On
review aggregator Rotten Tomatoes, the film holds an approval rating of based on critic reviews, with an average rating of . The website's critics consensus reads, "More bippity boppity than boo,
Godmothered tweaks fairytale conventions with just enough self-aware humor to overcome a disappointing deficit of genuine magic." On
Metacritic, it has a weighted average score of 49 out of 100 based on 12 critics, indicating "mixed or average" reviews. Alonso Duralde of
TheWrap praised the humor of the movie and the emotional weight across its ending, complimented the visual effects, and applauded the chemistry between Jillian Bell and Isla Fisher, writing "Younger viewers are more likely to find “Godmothered” enchanting, but there's enough good cheer (and smart messaging) for willing adults as well." Nick Allen of
RogerEbert.com gave the movie 3 out of 4 stars, praised the movie's humor, calling it a "charming family comedy", and complimented the performances of the actors, writing, "the cuteness of
Godmothered is a winning one overall, especially in how it uses a playful sense of humor and good heart to find its own way to Happily Ever After." Jennifer Green of
Common Sense Media rated the film 3 out of 5 stars and praised the film for its depiction of positive messages and role models, saying, "
Godmothered is a contemporary twist on the traditional Cinderella tale. [...] What
will stick is Eleanor's sweetness and humor and her total belief in fairy-tale concepts like princes, princesses, castles, carriages, magic, love, and happy endings. All of which get thrown into question in a lighthearted way that's meant to show kids that true love can come in many different forms and that happy endings aren't only about a man and a woman getting married." Robyn Bahr of
The Hollywood Reporter complimented the performances of the cast and found it to be an effective Christmas-themed film with a solid concept, but said
Godmothered never really manages to surprise its audience, writing, "
Godmothered is pleasant enough, a cheeky and nostalgic Christmas-themed family comedy [...] But
Godmothered would have distinguished itself with more narrational novelty." Natalia Winkelman of
The New York Times stated, "The film's idea is to re-examine and revise the fairy tale formula, and in some ways, it succeeds. [...] But for an updated princess story, Godmothered, directed by Sharon Maguire, is fairly conventional
."''
Kate Erbland of IndieWire'' gave the film a C− rating, stating, "Sharon Maguire's family comedy has a good heart and a clever central idea, but there's no shine left on this Disney+ bauble." ==Accolades==