Gone-Away Lake was a runner-up for the
Newbery Medal in 1958 (now called a Newbery Honor Book). It received the
New York Herald Tribune's Children's Spring Book Festival Award in 1957. In 1963 the American Library Association named
Gone-Away Lake as the U.S. nominee for the international
Hans Christian Andersen Award. It was named to the
Lewis Carroll Shelf Award list in 1970. Reviewers then and now praise Enright's excellent characterization, her use of description, and strong presentation of setting and nature in
Gone-Away Lake. A review by Irene Haas mentioned that "animals abound, and secrets and clubs, danger and daring". According to
Saturday Review, Enright "knows how to create real children". Children's book expert
May Hill Arbuthnot also praised Enright's fine use of description and observed, "Good prose style for any age level surprises and delights." In 2012
Gone-Away Lake was ranked number 42 among all-time best children's novels in a survey published by
School Library Journal – the first of three books by Enright in the top 100. ==See also==