Bill Coleman from
Billboard magazine described "Dub Be Good to Me" as a "
reggae-fied,
Soul II Soul-tinged reworking", adding that "big on import, stateside release sports the new remixes. Only misgiving is absence of fab original." Dave Sholin from the
Gavin Report noted that Cook from
the Housemartins takes this 1983 track by the
SOS Band, "beats and mixes well, and what emerges is a fresh delicacy for now tastes." He concluded, "Charts #1 in England and there's no reason to doubt it'll have a real good run in the States, too."
Simon Reynolds from
Melody Maker remarked that "the heartquake synths of the original [are] replaced by sonar bleeps, ocean bed alarums, lugubrious horns and a lonesome,
Midnight Cowboy harmonica. Just fine." Upon the
album release, another editor, Andrew Smith, wrote, "Out of this was fashioned a languid, smirking, gem of a tune, which we're probably all sick of by now. It nevertheless constitutes one of the finest shagging records ever made, proving once again that Norman Cook is a clever chap who knows a good bassline and how to filch it." Pan-European magazine
Music & Media described it as an "appealing mixture of
house and reggae", complimenting "good vocals by
Lindy and some tasteful
blues harmonica." Frank Owen from
Spin declared it as "an exquisite cover", adding further "Beats International has the distinctive languid air of lovers rock. A classy and pertinent fusion, 'Dub Be Good to Me' is similar in execution to the recent British import '
Wishing on a Star' by Fresh Four, featuring Lizz E. That bombed in this country, and so will this probably." ==Chart performance==