For the 1990 large-scale concert
The Wall – Live in Berlin, vocals for this song were provided by
Joni Mitchell, with visuals largely reprised from the film version. Roger Waters' 2010–13 tour
The Wall Live uses the song to depict a metaphorical "cultural bombing". As bomber planes fly in from the distance, they drop not bombs, but
dollar signs,
euro signs, religious symbols, and corporate logos. This imagery ended up attracting controversy due to the juxtaposition of dollar signs and the
Star of David, which was deemed antisemitic by the
Anti-Defamation League; Waters later removed the offending iconography and wrote an open letter to
The Independent clarifying that the Star was meant to critique the Israeli government. ==Personnel==