Wellington Phoenix In October 2021, Wisnewski joined
Wellington Phoenix in
A-League Women from
Hamilton Wanderers. Growing up a club fan, she joined their first women's team. She played every minute of all of the eleven games she played in the team's first season; she cut her season short to return to New Zealand when it lifted COVID-19 pandemic travel restrictions. She had struggled with her mental health and was contemplating quitting football. The break she took helped her be more excited about football, and six months later, she signed a new deal with the Phoenix in September 2022. She got a calf injury shortly afterward, keeping her from playing for some time. Back by April 2023, Wisnewski scored the latest-minute goal in regulation time in A-League history with what A-League statistician Andrew Howe called an "acrobatic equalizer" in the 99thminute of a match against defending league champions
Melbourne Victory, providing a 2–2 draw for the last-placed Phoenix.
Lexington SC In June 2024, Wisnewski announced she was departing Wellington Phoenix to explore other opportunities. On June 17, Wisnewski was announced as the first ever
USL Super League signing for
Lexington SC for the league's inaugural 2024-25 season. She made 13 appearances before leaving the club at the end of the season.
FC Nordsjaellland After joining Danish side
FC Nordsjaelland in the summer of 2025, she scored her first goal in the first qualifying round of the
2025–26 UEFA Women's Europa Cup in the second leg against Finish opponent
KuPS, with Nordsjaelland winning the tie 8-2 on aggregate. ==International career==