Evidence for the Great Oxidation Event is provided by a variety of petrological and geochemical markers that define this
geological event.
Continental indicators Paleosols, detrital grains, and red beds are evidence of low oxygen levels. Detrital grains composed of pyrite, siderite, and uraninite (redox-sensitive detrital minerals) are found in sediments older than ca. 2.4 Ga. These minerals are only stable under low oxygen conditions, and so their occurrence as detrital minerals in
fluvial and
deltaic sediments are widely interpreted as evidence of an anoxic atmosphere. In contrast to redox-sensitive detrital minerals are red beds, red-colored
sandstones that are coated with hematite. The occurrence of red beds indicates that there was sufficient oxygen to oxidize iron to its ferric state, and these represent a marked contrast to sandstones deposited under anoxic conditions which are often beige, white, grey, or green.
Banded iron formation Banded iron formations are composed of thin alternating layers of
chert (a fine-grained form of
silica) and iron oxides (
magnetite and hematite). Extensive deposits of this rock type are found around the world, almost all of which are more than 1.85 billion years old and most of which were deposited around 2.5
Ga. The iron in banded iron formations is partially oxidized, with roughly equal amounts of ferrous and ferric iron. Deposition of a banded iron formation requires both an anoxic deep ocean capable of transporting iron in soluble ferrous form, and an oxidized shallow ocean where the ferrous iron is oxidized to insoluble ferric iron and precipitates onto the ocean floor. The transition from deposition of banded iron formations to manganese oxides in some strata has been considered a key tipping point in the timing of the GOE because it is believed to indicate the escape of significant molecular oxygen into the atmosphere in the absence of ferrous iron as a reducing agent.
Iron speciation Black laminated
shales, rich in organic matter, are often regarded as a marker for
anoxic conditions. However, the deposition of abundant organic matter is not a sure indication of anoxia, and burrowing organisms that destroy
lamination had not yet evolved during the time frame of the Great Oxygenation Event. Thus laminated black shale by itself is a poor indicator of oxygen levels. Scientists must look instead for geochemical evidence of anoxic conditions. These include ferruginous anoxia, in which dissolved ferrous iron is abundant, and euxinia, in which
hydrogen sulfide is present in the water. Examples of such indicators of anoxic conditions include the degree of pyritization (DOP), which is the ratio of iron present as pyrite to the total reactive iron. Reactive iron, in turn, is defined as iron found in oxides and oxyhydroxides, carbonates, and reduced sulfur minerals such as pyrites, in contrast with iron tightly bound in silicate minerals. A DOP near zero indicates oxidizing conditions, while a DOP near 1 indicates euxinic conditions. Values of 0.3 to 0.5 are transitional, suggesting anoxic bottom mud under an oxygenated ocean. Studies of the
Black Sea, which is considered a modern model for ancient anoxic ocean basins, indicate that high DOP, a high ratio of reactive iron to total iron, and a high ratio of total iron to aluminum are all indicators of transport of iron into a euxinic environment. Ferruginous anoxic conditions can be distinguished from euxenic conditions by a DOP less than about 0.7. The presence of this signature all but eliminates the possibility of an oxygenated atmosphere. In addition to sulfur MIF, oxygen MIF signatures have also been argued as evidence for the oxygenation of Earth's atmosphere. As oxygen accumulates an ozone layer is established, and photochemical reactions involved in the destruction and reformation of ozone impart a mass independent isotope signature into atmospheric oxygen. Such signatures are preserved within sulfate minerals and existing records corroborate sulfur MIF inferences of oxygenation of the atmosphere in the early Paleoproterozoic. MIF provides clues to the Great Oxygenation Event. For example, oxidation of manganese in surface rocks by atmospheric oxygen leads to further reactions that oxidize chromium. The heavier Cr is oxidized preferentially over the lighter Cr, and the soluble oxidized chromium carried into the ocean shows this enhancement of the heavier isotope. The chromium isotope ratio in banded iron formation suggests small but significant quantities of oxygen in the atmosphere before the Great Oxidation Event, and a brief return to low oxygen abundance 500
Ma after the GOE. However, the chromium data may conflict with the sulfur isotope data, which calls the reliability of the chromium data into question. It is also possible that oxygen was present earlier only in localized "oxygen oases". Since chromium is not easily dissolved, its release from rocks requires the presence of a powerful acid such as
sulfuric acid (H2SO4) which may have formed through bacterial oxidation of pyrite. This could provide some of the earliest evidence of oxygen-breathing life on land surfaces. Other elements whose MIF may provide clues to the GOE include carbon, nitrogen, transitional metals such as
molybdenum and iron, and non-metal elements such as
selenium. Structures that are claimed to be fossils of cyanobacteria exist in rock formed 3.5
Ga. These include microfossils of supposedly cyanobacterial cells and macrofossils called
stromatolites, which are interpreted as colonies of microbes, including cyanobacteria, with characteristic layered structures. Modern stromatolites, which can only be seen in harsh environments such as
Shark Bay in Western Australia, are associated with cyanobacteria, and thus fossil stromatolites had long been interpreted as the evidence for cyanobacteria. Additionally, Archaean sedimentary rocks were once found to contain
biomarkers, also known as
chemical fossils, interpreted as fossilized membrane lipids from cyanobacteria and
eukaryotes. For example, traces of 2α-methylhopanes and steranes that are thought to be derived from cyanobacteria and eukaryotes, respectively, were found in the
Pilbara of Western Australia.
Steranes are diagenetic products of sterols, which are biosynthesized using molecular oxygen. Thus, steranes can additionally serve as an indicator of oxygen in the atmosphere. However, these biomarker samples have since been shown to have been contaminated, and so the results are no longer accepted. Carbonaceous microfossils from the Turee Creek Group of Western Australia, which date back to ~2.45–2.21 Ga, have been interpreted as
iron-oxidising bacteria. Their presence suggests a minimum threshold of seawater oxygen content had been reached by this interval of time.
Other indicators Some elements in marine sediments are sensitive to different levels of oxygen in the environment such as the
transition metals
molybdenum Non-metal elements such as selenium and iodine are also indicators of oxygen levels. == Hypotheses ==