McMurtry was selected by the Patriots in the third round (80th overall pick) of the
1990 NFL draft. As a rookie during the
1990 NFL season, McMurtry appeared in 13 games, five as a starter, and caught 22 passes for 240 yards. The following year, he enjoyed his best season in the NFL, catching 41 passes for 614 yards and two touchdowns. During the
1992 NFL season, McMurtry appeared in all 16 games for the Patriots, 15 as a starter, and caught 35 passes for 424 yards and one touchdown. In 1993, McMurtry's final season with the Patriots, he appeared in 14 games, eight as a starter, and caught 22 passes for 241 yards and a touchdown. McMurtry appeared in nine games for the Bears, four as a starter, during the
1994 NFL season. He caught eight passes for 112 yards and one touchdown. During his five-year NFL career, McMurtry had 128
receptions for 1,631 yards and five touchdowns. ==NFL career statistics==