Colorado Rockies Reynolds made his Major League Baseball debut on May 11, , in a 6–1 road loss against the
San Diego Padres. He allowed four
earned runs on six
hits and
struck out one batter in
innings. On June 7, Reynolds picked up his first career
win and hit as a pitcher, in a 7–2 home victory over the
Milwaukee Brewers. He pitched six innings, allowing two earned runs on four hits, with no strikeouts. His first career hit, a
double, occurred in the bottom of the second inning off Brewers pitcher
Dave Bush. In 2009, Reynolds appeared in just one game due to injury. In 2010, he split time between the High-A
Modesto Nuts and Double-A
Tulsa Drillers, compiling a 8–6 record and 4.74 ERA with 51 strikeouts in innings pitched across 19 starts. On May 22, 2011, Reynolds was called up to replace struggling
Felipe Paulino. Reynolds went 3-0 for the Rockies but with an ERA of 6.19 in 13 games. He was sent outright to the Triple-A
Colorado Springs Sky Sox on October 5.
Texas Rangers On January 5, 2012, Reynolds was traded to the
Texas Rangers for
Chad Tracy. He elected free agency following the season on November 2.
Cincinnati Reds On January 10, 2013, Reynolds signed a minor league contract with the
Cincinnati Reds. He began the season with Triple-A
Louisville, where in 18 starts before his callup, he went 10–2 with a 2.54 ERA, striking out 79 in innings. On July 23, Reynolds was called up to start the second game of a
doubleheader against the
San Francisco Giants. In his start, he went 5 innings giving up 5 runs, taking the loss. On July 28, he was designated for assignment. He cleared waivers and was sent outright to Triple-A
Louisville Bats on July 31. Reynolds had his contract selected to the major league roster again on August 25. He became a free agent following the season.
Saitama Seibu Lions On December 27, 2013, Reynolds signed with the
Saitama Seibu Lions of
Nippon Professional Baseball. In 12 starts for Seibu, he posted a 3–7 record and 5.46 ERA with 29 strikeouts over 61 innings of work. Reynolds was released by the Lions on September 20, 2014.
San Diego Padres On February 11, 2016, Reynolds signed a minor league contract by the
San Diego Padres. In 5 starts for the Triple-A
El Paso Chihuahuas, he struggled to a 1–3 record and 7.30 ERA with five strikeouts across innings pitched. Reynolds was released by the Padres organization on May 6. ==Personal life==