Plot The story begins at the court of
Emperor Conrad, who for all of his good qualities has one defect: he refuses to get married, especially since, as he says, people no longer are as valiant and as noble as they used to be. His
minstrel, Jouglet, tells him of Guillaume de Dole and his sister Liénor, and quickly the emperor falls in love with her, although he does not actually see her until the story's
denouement. Guillaume is summoned to the court where he excels in chivalric exploits; the emperor tells him he wishes to marry his sister. Conrad's jealous
seneschal interferes and visits Guillaume's family, where he gives his mother a valuable ring and gains her confidence; from her he learns that Liénor has a particular birthmark in the shape of a rose on her thigh. This knowledge is presented as proof that the seneschal has taken her virginity. As for the seneschal, Liénor implores Conrad to be merciful, and he is sent away as a Templar to join a crusade.
Themes The plot of
Guillaume revolves around the common theme of the
gageure, a young man who, because of a wager (in the case of
Guillaume, because of jealousy) needs to find a young woman's favor. He fails in his enterprise but pretends publicly to have succeeded, causing the ruin of a husband (if the
gageure had claimed to have succeeded with another man's wife) or, in this case, the despair of a brother. Usually the young man's story is believed at first because he reveals an intimate detail about a young woman, who then has to prove her innocence. Beginning with Michel Zink, whose influential 1979 monograph
Roman rose et rose rouge: Le Roman de la rose ou de Guillaume de Dole ushered in a new era of criticism, critics have recognized
Guillaume de Dole as a work of literature about literature, a self-referential poem that comments on the improbability of some of its own plot elements and on its own fictional status, encouraging a trend in studies of Renart and his work.
Songs The romance contains some 46 chansons, which can be separated into two groups, according to Hollier and Bloch. The first group contains sixteen "aristocratic"
chansons courtoises on the topic of
courtly love, attributed to specific
trouvères or
troubadours (including
Gace Brulé,
Le Chastelain de Couci,
Guillaume de Ferrières (the
Vidame de Chartres),
Jaufre Rudel, and
Bernart de Ventadorn). A second group consists of thirty mostly anonymous songs of a more popular nature, such as three
chansons de toile and three other ballads, two
pastourelles, and twenty
chansons à danser (dance songs). Incorporated also is a
laisse of the
chanson de geste Gerbert de Metz. In its hybrid form,
Guillaume de Dole is "the first extant example of the combined use of narrative and lyric in French." The mixed form proved to be popular and was soon found in other works, including
Aucassin and Nicolette (early 13th century);
Gautier de Coincy's
Les Miracles de Nostre-Dame (c. 1218–1233);
Gerbert de Montreuil's
Le Roman de la Violette (c. 1230), which incorporates some forty songs; and Tibaut's
Roman de la Poire (c. 1250), which incorporates a series of refrains. By the end of the century the form had become canonical.
Female protagonist The female protagonist, Liénor, is notable because of her active nature: she herself unmasks the seneschal. She found a quick successor in the active female protagonist of Tibaut's
Roman de la Poire. At least one recent publication states that Liénor might make a justifiable claim to being the romance's true hero. ==Editorial and critical history==