Critical response On
Rotten Tomatoes, the series holds an approval rating of 81% based on 31 reviews, with an average rating of 7.6/10. The website's critical consensus reads: "Intelligent and thought-provoking,
Awake tempts audiences with an original and complex concept that keeps them guessing."
Awake drew strong reviews for its pilot. Rachel Ray of
The Daily Telegraph called the premiere episode "impressive", while
NPR's
Linda Holmes said that it laid the foundation for several emotional storylines, evaluating it among the strongest shows in recent memory.
James Poniewozik of
Time noted that while its concept seemed melodramatic, the episode "focuses unflinchingly on the subject of loss, yet manages to be not a downer or painful to watch, but moving, absorbing and even hopeful." Isaacs' performance garnered praise throughout the run of the series. Curt Wagner of
RedEye said: "his touching, solid work grounds everything. He shows viewers what lengths one man in pain might go to hold onto those he loves. And it's heartbreaking." Matt Fowler of
IGN said Isaacs "delivers a graceful and subdued performance as a man who, on a daily basis, must taste both heaven and hell. A man full of guilt, but also gratitude." Some critics called for Isaacs to receive an
Emmy Award. In contrast, some viewers were unimpressed with
Awake. Writing for
The Washington Post, Hank Stuever felt that despite high ambitions the pilot episode was slow and drowsy. Certain episodes were singled out for particularly poor quality: "Game Day" was called "childishly simple", "Ricky's Tacos" was criticized for too closely resembling
Law & Order: Special Victims Unit, and "Nightswimming" was described as uneven and boring.
US television ratings Awake had low viewership and ratings throughout its original run. The premiere episode started strong, becoming the most-viewed program in its time slot for NBC in almost two years. but its second episode fell by two million viewers,
Awards and accolades In June 2011
Awake was honored, along with seven others, with the
Critics' Choice Television Award for Most Exciting New Series, chosen by journalists who had seen the pilots.
ET Online chose Isaacs as its first actor in their annual Emmy Preview, which predicts winners of particular
Emmy Awards.
ET Online reviewer Jarett Wieselman noted that Isaacs could receive an
Outstanding Lead Actor in a Drama Series nomination; == Distribution ==