Early reviews of the promotional version of the game received by redeeming a code that came with
Guitar Hero 5 were critical of the game.
IGNs Erik Brudvig rated the game 4.9/10, citing problems with the lack of relevance of Van Halen relative to the culture of the 2000s, including having their avatars based on their current appearances rather than that of their 80s heyday, the lack of songs from Sammy Hagar's period in the band, and the lack of features since introduced with
Guitar Hero 5. Brudvig ultimately stated that those who got the game free through the
Guitar Hero 5 promotion "got what they paid for". Robert Workman of
Game Daily was less critical of the title, but still noted that the game lacked features, including some mention of Hagar and Gary Cherone and songs from their period with the band, and felt that the title was below the quality of
Guitar Hero: Metallica. Both Brudvig and Workman commented positively on the sound recordings and the note tracking of the Van Halen songs. Philip Horton of
The Telegraph was critical of the game's song selection, the band's modern appearance, and the lack of any additional extras compared with either the previous band-centric games or
Guitar Hero 5, and described it as "the weakest offering in the series to date". Kate Carter of
The Guardian commented that the game is "neither one thing or the other", as it neither succeeds at bringing anything new to the
Guitar Hero series nor fully pays tribute to Van Halen.
Computer and Video Games' review complained about the "shoddy character models" and described it as "the laziest
Guitar Hero yet", As of April 2010, the game has sold fewer than 250,000 copies worldwide, with only 95,000 units sold in North America. These numbers do not include copies of the game distributed in conjunction with
Guitar Hero 5. ==References==