Guy and Madeline on a Park Bench received positive reviews from film critics. On
Metacritic, the film holds a rating of 83 out of 100, based on eleven critics, indicating "universal acclaim". The film premiered to a strong critical reception during its festival run.
The Village Voice called the film "the kind of movie a young
Cassavetes might have made were he working for MGM's Freed Unit".
The Boston Globe called it "the most buzzed-about movie at the prestigious Tribeca Film Festival".
Time Out New York called it "blissful, brilliant", and noted "one sequence involving a tap dancer, a jam session, and a house party is arguably the most joyous five minutes you're likely to experience in a theater". Several reviewers called the film a "
mumblecore musical". Amy Taubin of
Film Comment, John Anderson of
Variety, David Fear of
Time Out New York and Elizabeth Weitzman of
New York Daily News named it the best undistributed film of the year in 2009, and
indieWIRE named it the #3 Best Undistributed Film of 2009 in its year-end critics' poll. ==References==