Elections During the
2019 Cebu local elections, Garcia ran for
governor of Cebu as a candidate of the
PDP–Laban /
One Cebu Party coalition and won against
NPC candidate
Agnes Magpale. Her brother
Pablo John Garcia won the seat she vacated – the third
congressional district of Cebu of the
House of Representatives. She was re-elected in
2022, but lost reelection in 2025 to
Pam Baricuatro, marking her first electoral defeat in her political career.
Tenure COVID-19 pandemic: public shaming and promotion of alternative medicine On May 18, 2020, Garcia held a briefing with the local press where she usually goes over the latest COVID-19 updates in the province. This briefing was also aired on Facebook Live. During the press conference, she pulled out large sheets of paper with Facebook comments printed on them, while having the posts broadcast on half the screen through Sugbo News, the province's public information office. Garcia began to publicly shame a netizen in retaliation for Facebook comments criticizing and insulting her and her provincial government. This action was met with criticism and backlash on social media, as well as the Commission on Human Rights (CHR) for publicly exposing and belittling the personal information of said netizen. Garcia questioned the doctor's qualifications and undermined her years of experience, even telling her to run for office if she was confident about her medical knowledge. Rep. Garcia said their brothers tested positive for COVID-19 "but they recovered and what happened after was the cause of their deaths." Governor said that based on the death certificate, Nelson Garcia died due to "immediate cardio pulmonary arrest secondary to probable massive embolism". For Marlon Garcia, the cause of death was "septic shock secondary to catheter related blood stream infection, ventilator associated pneumonia."
HSBC 1996 loan dispute In September 2024, the
Supreme Court of the Philippines released a December 4, 2023 ruling on a 1996 loan litigation stating that Garcia should pay
Hongkong and Shanghai Banking Corporation $700,000 with 12% legal interest from July 2000, and P404,560.50 in legal costs.
2025 suspension On March 20, 2024, Mayor
Michael Rama, her fellow
PDP–Laban member, filed an administrative complaint before the
Office of President and sought the
suspension of Garcia regarding the
Cebu Bus Rapid Transit System. Garcia issued a memorandum to stop the CBRT construction in heritage buffer zones of the
Cebu Provincial Capitol and
Fuente Osmeña Circle on February 27, 2024. Garcia eventually resigned as a member of PDP on May 28, 2024. On April 28, 2025, the Ombudsman imposed a six-month suspension on Garcia for issuing a construction permit to a private firm without securing clearance from the
Department of Environment and Natural Resources. Despite this, Garcia refused to step down. After leaving office, Garcia was fined P1.2 million in August 2025 by the Ombudsman for illegal dredging operations from a protected nature reserve along the Manganga River in
Talisay when she was governor in 2024. This was overturned by the
Court of Appeals in March 2026. == Public profile ==