Loreto, Beaufort Matthews played in three
Leinster Schoolgirls' Senior Cup finals for
Loreto Beaufort, each time playing against teams that included future
Ireland team mates. In the 2006 final Loreto, Beaufort lost 2–0 to
St. Andrew's College. 13-year-old
Chloe Watkins scored St Andrew's second goal. In the 2008 final Matthews scored the winner from a
penalty corner as Loreto, Beaufort defeated an
Alexandra College team featuring
Nicola Evans and
Deirdre Duke 2–1. In the 2009 final Matthews captained Loreto, Beaufort as they faced a St. Andrew's team featuring Chloe Watkins and
Gillian Pinder. This time St. Andrew's won 2–0 after extra time.
DCU Matthews played for
Dublin City University at intervarsity level, featuring in the 2009, 2010 and 2012 Chilean Cup tournaments. Her DCU team mates included
Alison Meeke.
Loreto In 2008–09 Matthews was a member of the
Loreto team that won the inaugural
Women's Irish Hockey League title. In the 2009–10
Irish Senior Cup final against
Railway Union, Matthews scored the winning
penalty stroke in a
penalty shoot-out after the game had finished 2–2. Matthews also scored for Loreto in the 2011–12 final but this time they lost 3–2 against
UCD. Matthews has also represented Loreto in
European competitions. In June 2011 she scored in the EuroHockey Club Champion's Challenge II final as Loreto defeated HC Olten of
Switzerland 7–1. In 2014 she captained Loreto to third place at the European Club Championship Trophy tournament hosted by
Leicester Hockey Club. In May 2018 Matthews captained Loreto as they won the
EY Champions Trophy. Matthews team mates at Loreto have included
Nikki Symmons,
Lizzie Colvin,
Alison Meeke,
Nicola Daly ==Ireland international==