At
Metacritic, which assigns a normalised rating out of 100 to reviews from mainstream publications, the album has an
average score of 68 based on 24 reviews, indicating "generally favorable reviews".
Rolling Stones
Rob Sheffield states that Styles "claims his turf as a true rock & roll prince" on his "superb solo debut".
Annie Zaleski of
The A.V. Club felt Styles took a "bold step forward by leaning on the past", adding, "hopefully the songs will someday catch up to his ambition". Mesfin Fekadu of
Associated Press noted the performance aspect of the album is where Styles "truly shines", but "not so much" in the creative process. Anjali Raguraman of
The Straits Times called "Sign of the Times" the "strongest" track on the album and felt Styles sounds "most self-assured on the slower numbers", while noting that "his inexperience shows when he falls into tired tropes". In a negative review, Dave Hanratty of
Drowned in Sound felt that Styles "failed to make a defining statement", writing that the album "from start to finish [...] is a series of impressions" of
Elton John,
Beck,
Mick Jagger, and
The Beatles. Neil McCormick of
The Daily Telegraph wrote that, compared to the other One Direction member's solo careers, Styles' is "more eccentric but more appealing, with an endearing quality of relish in its musical adventures", calling the album "so old-fashioned it may actually come across as something new to its target audience" and "perfectly lovely and about as substantial as ripples on the surface of a Beverly Hills swimming pool". Leah Greenblaat of
Entertainment Weekly named Styles "a man proudly looking backward, a faithful revivalist steeped in the tao of dusty vinyl and dad rock" while noting that he "basks in the privilege of paying tribute to his many musical heroes, and trying on all the styles that fit". Leonie Cooper of
NME described the album as "a not-that-bad-actually mish-mash of Los Angeles' style classic rock and ballads", commenting that fans will be "over the moon with this collection of radio-friendly rockers and heartstring tugging balladry" and "everyone else" will be "pleasantly surprised – if not a little taken aback at just how many tricks he’s pinched from other artists". She ends the review by opining that "taking inspiration from the best seems to have paid dividends, but it doesn’t half make you wonder what the real Harry Styles sounds like". Jamieson Cox of
Pitchfork wrote that the record "pays fine tribute to classic rock’n’roll and shows off his exceptional voice, if not his enigmatic persona", opining that his "vocal performances are invariably the best parts of these songs" while particuraly praising the album's last track, "From the Dining Table", writing that "it’s intoxicating, and it ends
Harry Styles on the most promising possible note". Retrospectively, the album has received acclaim from publications who were initially critical of the project. In 2022,
Consequence of Sound retracted their low grade of the album, stating "The man’s solo debut was not C+ material [...] What’s odd is that the initial review that ran on
Consequence is overwhelmingly complimentary — we’re happy to now set the record straight and confirm that Styles’ debut solo record is a great one." In 2024,
American Songwriter named Styles' debut as the most impressive solo debut following a band breakup.
Year-end lists ==Commercial performance==