Though no longer suitable for collegiate hockey, Hartmeyer was still the premier skating, amateur hockey and youth hockey facility in Madison for many years and one of few in the region capable of holding over 3,000 spectators. The
Patriots Youth Hockey Association began using the arena in 1984 and still holds many events in the facility. Since 2006, Hartmeyer Ice Arena has also been home to the Madison Eastside Lakers Hockey team a Co-Op team consisting of Madison La Follette High School and Madison East High School. Prior to 2006 La Follette and East had separate hockey teams. The Eastside Lakers formed another co-op that still occasionally uses Hartmeyer.
Monona Grove High School calls Hartmeyer its home ice, having their own locker rooms for Varsity and Junior Varsity. The City of Madison operated Hartmeyer into the 21st century, despite the arena beginning to show signs of age. With an older surface that did not fare well in warmer months and competition from newer facilities, the arena became a financial strain to the city. In 2004, it was sold, along with the Madison Ice Arena, to Madison Ice, Inc., a
not-for-profit organization committed to supporting skating and youth hockey in the Madison area. In 2008, Madison Ice paid for improvements to the surface, allowing for the facility to be used year-round. On September 25, 2010, Hartmeyer celebrated its 50th anniversary with a free, open-skating day for the general public. ==Wisconsin Wolfpack==