Academics and personal development Negative aspects Graduation rates among members of HBCU marching bands tend to lag behind those of the general population of the institutions.
Positive aspects Research by Henry Taylor Frierson concluded that HBCU marching bands represent an ideal institution for development of black male youth by supporting positive identity formation and a customized support structure. Meanwhile, 83.9-percent stated their feeling that most people attended HBCU football games only to see the marching band perform.
Gender roles The position of drum major at HBCUs has traditionally been dominated by men. In 2018, the first female drum major at Florida A&M University was selected in that band's 72-year history.
Hazing Several sources have reported on endemic hazing within HBCU bands. In 2011,
NPR reported that – at one school – new members "had to face choreographed assaults, with two-by-fours, belts, baseball bats ... suffering literally hundreds of blows from their older compatriots". A limited survey conducted in 2013 by Bruce Allen Carter of the
National Council on the Arts found that
gay males who were members of an HBCU band experienced "ever-present anxiety" when participating in band-related activities. Each survey participant also reported being subject to hazing that was so "shameful and embarrassing" that it was "not something they ever discussed".
Racial issues HBCU bands tend to be predominantly African-American, though occasionally persons of other races have been members. According to a 2012 study, white students attending an HBCU generally avoided social activities and focused on academics, however, if they were a member of the school's band they "appeared to develop strong relationships with their peers" within the ensemble. In 2001, Matt Smith became the first white drum major at
Hampton University. According to Smith, some opposing schools would use Smith's race to demean the group as a whole. From 2018 to 2020, Justin Heideman, who is white, was head drum major of the
Jefferson Davis High School (Montgomery, Alabama) marching band, an HBCU-style high school band. In the second year of Heideman's tenure, after video of one of the band's performances was posted online, Heideman encountered – according to
USA Today – "hate, ignorance and prejudice" in a minority of online comments to the video, with some suggesting "there was something heinous about a group of black children following the lead of a white boy". ==In popular culture==