Richard D. James Album received acclaim from music critics. In the United Kingdom,
The Independent Ben Thompson wrote that "The intuitive sense of melody [James has] been striving so hard to suppress over the last few years has come to the fore too, and the result is the most magical
pop record of the year: the year in question being AD 2001."
NME reviewer Ted Kessler praised its sense of "fresh musical perception" and called it "a record that's absorbed the rhythmic advances made by drum'n'bass in places... yet scribbles furiously over its roots with sparkly chemical melodies and splintered clanging".
Entertainment Weekly writer
David Browne called it James' "quirkiest, most personal work" and said that "4" and "Girl/Boy Song" revealed "a new warmth and wistfulness".
Richard D. James Album was placed in numerous best-of lists.
NME placed the album at number 20 on their list of the best albums of 1996.
The Wire also listed the album among their top 50 albums of the year for 1996. In 2003
Pitchfork listed their top albums of the 1990s, with
Richard D. James Album ranking at 40.
Slant Magazine placed the album at number 91 on their list of the top 100 albums of the 1990s, describing it as "more fascinated by textures than almost any other electronic album ever crafted". In 2015
Spin placed the album at number 71 on their list of the best albums of the past 30 years. In the same year,
Exclaim! listed
Richard D. James Album on their list of Essential Richard D. James albums. The review opined that the album was "not necessarily a release that you immediately fall in love with", but that it was "endlessly rewarding". ==Track listing==