Cribioli played with various different clubs in South America before playing abroad in 1960 in the
National Soccer League with
Toronto Italia. The team secured the NSL Championship after a series of matches against Montreal Cantalia. In 1961, league rivals Toronto Roma decided to increase their spending on the transfer market in order to compete with Toronto Italia over league dominance and the attention of the
Italian community within the city. As a result, signed Cribiolo for the 1961 season. His spell with Roma was rather brief as he was transferred to
Limoges FC of the
Division Nationale on July 13, 1961, for a league record fee of $35,000. The remainder of the season he played in the
Belgian First Division with
R.F.C. Liege., and ultimately returned to Canada the following season After a year hiatus he would return to play with RFC Liege in 1963 and featured in the
1963–64 Inter-Cities Fairs Cup, and
1964–65 Inter-Cities Fairs Cup. After a short tenure in Europe he returned in 1962 to play with former club Toronto Italia this time in the
Eastern Canada Professional Soccer League as the club became a charter member in 1961. In his debut season in the Eastern Canada Professional League (ECPSL) he was selected by team Italia-Roma Selects for the All-Star match and contributed a goal. He featured in the ECPSL Championship final match against
Toronto City, and assisted in securing the title for Italia. == Honors ==