NBC announced on May 16, 2005, that
Trial by Jury would not be returning for the 2005–2006 fall television season. The rival
CBS procedural Numbers debuted in the midseason in late January 2005 and consistently beat NBC's
Medical Investigation in the ratings, sending the latter show into hiatus and eventual cancellation, freeing up the time slot for
Law & Order: Trial by Jury. Despite
Trial by Jurys pedigree,
Numbers ratings remained strong, often beating
Trial by Jury in both overall and key demographic ratings. In an October 2005 interview with the
Associated Press, Wolf stated that NBC had assured him
Trial by Jury would return for the fall of 2005, but had "blindsided" him by canceling it instead. Though still having reasonable ratings that could have given the series a second season, the main reason for the cancellation according to Kevin Reilly, NBC's brand-new president of entertainment at the time, was due to the networks acquisition of Sunday Night Football for what was coming in the 2005–2006 season, which took away programming space for NBC. As Reilly would state, "Now that we have football [on Sundays, beginning in 2006], we only have five nights of entertainment programming. When we had six nights, we could accommodate four
Law & Orders."
Trial by Jury was the first series of the
Law & Order franchise to be canceled. The sets were reused by a series Wolf produced for NBC entitled
Conviction which premiered Friday, March 3, 2006, lasting only one season before cancellation. The network
Court TV (now TruTV) re-aired the entire series, including the episode "Eros in the Upper Eighties", which never aired on NBC before the series was canceled. TNT has aired the episode "Skeleton" on occasion, as the conclusion to the original series episode "Tombstone". The opening track and some of the intro sequences from
Trial by Jury would be re-used in
Law & Order: Criminal Intent after their show was transferred to the
USA Network and remained until its own cancellation in 2011. ==Home media==