Critical reception The second season received a 60 out of 100 aggregate score, based on nine reviews, indicating "mixed or average" reception at
Metacritic. Ken Tucker of
Entertainment Weekly gave the season start a B+, calling it "visually impressive," adding "the show rises or falls each week on the strength of the moments when Anson Mount|[Anson] Mount and
Common dominate. Each actor in his own way is capable of lifting
Hell on Wheels to the level the series so clearly wants to attain: a fresh take on the old macho code of a-man's-gotta-do-what-a-man's-gotta-do, without posturing or a self-consciousness about the century of
Westerns that have preceded it."
Salons Willa Paskin called the new season "a perfectly adequate piece of television with above adequate production values", adding "even if Westerns aren't particularly your thing,
Hell on Wheels doesn't hurt to watch, if, you know, it's not actually
fun to watch." Verne Gay of
Newsday gave it a B− and stated "the cast [...] is good, while the
Old West still feels especially beautiful and perilous."
New York Magazines Matt Zoller Seitz stated the show "still looks and sounds great, has a mostly capable cast, and delivers flat-out terrific Elam scenes, large-scale action set pieces, and lantern-lit images that reminded of
The Assassination of Jesse James by the Coward Robert Ford. But the rest is wasted motion." Maureen Ryan of
The Huffington Post found the second season "marginally better paced and the characters moderated a bit from the broad archetypes seen in
Season 1," but added "It's a mystery to me how something about the building of railroad can so often fail to take advantage of the literal engine at its core." The AV Club gave Season 2 a grade of B− overall, but suggested that it might be the last.
Ratings The second-season premiere was watched by just over 2.5 million viewers and 793,000 adults aged 18–49, a 0.6
Nielsen rating. The numbers were down significantly from the first season's premiere and finale. The first-season premiere had a lead-in program in
The Walking Dead. The two-hour finale was watched by 2.18 million viewers and received a 0.6 18-49 rating. == References ==