St. Clair Morgan
, including
R. W. McGavock (top) and St. Clair Morgan (bottom left)
St. Clair McIntosh Morgan was a first cousin of Confederate cavalry officer
John Hunt Morgan. Morgan was appointed from Tennessee to the
United States Military Academy, in the same class as
Jerome Bonaparte,
Alexander McCook, and
Philip Sheridan. However, in the class registers for 1849, 1850, and 1851, Morgan typically had the lowest grades and the highest number of demerits. Morgan submitted his resignation to the academy in 1851, per a letter held in a collection of his father's papers at the
Tennessee State Library. According to the USMA Archives and Special Collections Division, Morgan resigned June 20, 1851, "deficient in Natural and Experimental Philosophy." Morgan's
Cullum number is x-1852. Some early reports of the duel claimed "Morgan is the man who fired the first shot at the
Star of the West" from
Morris Island in
Charleston Harbor. Current thinking generally attributes the first shot at the
Star of the West to
Citadel Cadet
George E. Haynesworth. In April 1861 the
Chicago Tribune commented on the claim: "[Morgan] left
Charleston in January in consequence of a fight with a New Yorker, Capt.
Amos Colt, agent for the sale of
Col. Colt's arms; the quarrel being forced on Colt by the Tennessean, who accused Colt of being the
New York Tribune's correspondent, and struck him with a glove, when Colt incontinently gave him a most deserved thrashing in the hall fronting the counter of the
Charleston Hotel, some fifty persons witnessing the scene. Something like a challenge passed subsequently, but nothing came of it, and Morgan found so cold South Carolinian shoulders turned upon him in consequence, that he presently departed for Florida. With respect to his being the man who fired upon the
Star of the West, the statement may be true, or a bit of lying braggadocia. There were many claimants to the
honor in Charleston, which was not generally assigned to St Clair." The
Tribune concluded this paragraph with the assertion that Morgan's mother, Matilda Grant Rose McIntosh Morgan, had once been tried in a court of law for whipping an enslaved girl to death. He enlisted September 1, 1861, and became Captain of a company of the
10th Tennessee (Confederate). The company he organized may have mustered in at
Fort Donelson. Morgan was killed at the
Battle of Chickamauga. == George S. Storrs ==