Hilton was born in
Newburgh, New York on October 4, 1824, the youngest son of a Scottish immigrant. Campbell & Cleveland represented
A.T. Stewart, "The Merchant Prince," and Hilton became Stewart's private counsel in 1850. In the 1850s Hilton married Ellen Banker, a cousin of Mrs. Stewart and the sister of James H. Banker, President of the
Bank of New York. He was a judge of the Court of Common Pleas from 1858 to 1863, and also served as Parks Commissioner for a time. Mr. Stewart died in 1876, and Hilton served as his
executor, receiving a bequest of one million dollars for his services, which Mrs. Stewart paid by transferring the business of A.T. Stewart to him. In 1886 Mrs. Stewart died and Hilton again served as executor. Judge Hilton retired from A.T. Stewart in 1883. There are two different accounts of his success in business. According to his biography, "he was entirely successful, and when he retired in 1883 ... his sons and son-in-law succeeded to the business and soon dissipated the property." According to the
New York Times, however, Hilton presided over "the dissipation of one of the greatest fortunes ever amassed by trade." ==Woodlawn==