Onderdonk was elected assistant bishop of Pennsylvania in 1827, serving initially as assistant to Bishop
William White. He was the
21st bishop of the ECUSA, and was consecrated by bishops William White,
Alexander Viets Griswold, and
James Kemp. However, bishop Kemp died of injuries received in a stage coach accident while returning from the consecration, so Onderdonk substituted in the
Episcopal Diocese of Maryland until a successor was elected. In 1830, Onderdonk published
Episcopacy Tested In Scripture, first published in the
Protestant Episcopalian and then as tract by the Protestant Episcopal Tract Society, a defense of episcopacy based "on
an appeal to the bible alone." On Bishop White's death in 1836, Onderdonk succeeded him as bishop. In 1844, Onderdonk was suspended from the exercise of his Episcopal office after rumors of
alcoholism. The suspension was lifted in 1856, two years before his death. He is buried in the churchyard of
Church of St. James the Less in
Philadelphia. ==Notes==