Wace was born in
Shrewsbury, and educated at
Shrewsbury School and
St. John's College, Cambridge. He won
blues in both association football and
rugby in 1874 and 1875. In the 1875
Football Annual, Wace was described as "a very good and dangerous 'centre' (who) plays pluckily and sticks to the ball; at times (he) gets a little too far forward". It was until the 1876–77 season, however, that he became a regular member of the side and went on to make a total of 38 appearances at
centre-forward scoring 18 goals, In 1876–77, Wace played in all four matches in the
FA Cup, when Wanderers reached the final for the second consecutive year (and the fourth since the competition was inaugurated in 1871), where they defeated
Oxford University 2–1 in extra time. The following year, Wace again appeared in all six
FA Cup matches including scoring twice in each of the victories over Panthers and High Wycombe. In
the final against the
Royal Engineers, Wace and the team captain
Arthur Kinnaird were soon creating problems for the Engineers' defence, resulting in an early goal when
Jarvis Kenrick converted "an excellent pass" from Wace. The game finished 3–1 to the Wanderers who thus claimed the cup for the fifth time in the first seven years of the competition. Three weeks prior to the
1878 FA Cup Final, Wace was one of seven débutantes selected for the friendly international against
Scotland. Although the England selectors had fielded a side that they considered capable of defeating the Scots, the home side had other ideas and scored seven goals with a hat-trick from
John McDougall and two goals each from
Billy MacKinnon and
Henry McNeil; England replied through
John Wylie and
Arthur Cursham. In the aftermath of this "humiliating" defeat, it became clear that England would have to change their style of play if they were to compete with the Scottish passing game which was far more productive than the English style which relied on dribbling. Wace retained his place for the next international against
Wales at the
Kennington Oval on 18 January 1879. The match was played in a blizzard and both captains agreed to play halves of only 30 minutes each. This was the first match between the two countries – Wales had previously only played three international matches, all against Scotland, including a 9–0 defeat in March 1878. England's two goals came from débutantes,
Herbert Whitfeld and
Thomas Sorby, with
William Davies scoring for Wales. According to the football historian, Philip Gibbons, "England were surprised by the level of skill shown by the Welsh team". For the annual match against Scotland played at the Oval on 5 April 1879, Wace retained his place and was appointed
captain. Once again, the England selectors made numerous changes with eight players making their debut. Apart from Wace, only
Norman Bailey and
Billy Mosforth had previous international experience. By half-time the Scots had taken a 4–1 lead, but England fought back to equalise. With eight minutes remaining, the Scots had the ball in the net but the "goal" was disallowed for offside; England promptly raced upfield with
Charlie Bambridge scoring on his debut, to give England their first victory over the Scots since 1873 in what was considered to be "the most exciting England and Scotland game to date". In February 1880, Wace scored the consolation goal in a 3–1 defeat by
Old Etonians thus scoring Wanderers' final goal in the FA Cup. His final appearance came on 23 October 1880; shortly afterwards, the club was disbanded. Later, he played for
Clapham Rovers and
Shropshire Wanderers.
International appearances Wace made three appearances for England as follows: ==Professional career==