The album was not well received, as stylistically it veered from their earlier fusion of
progressive rock and
heavy rock into more mainstream territory, lacking the group's signature lengthy compositions and fantastical,
mythically orientated lyrical subject matter. "Several of the songs find the band flirting with pop elements in a way that doesn't complement their hard rocking style", said Donald A. Guarisco in his retrospective
AllMusic review. He added that
High and Mighty "shows flashes of the group's old firepower, but is ultimately sunk by a combination of unfocused experimentation and uneven songwriting".
Martin Popoff called the album "effeminate, illogical, overblown, grasping for straws", citing only the song "One Way or Another" as "promising" and the rest a squandering of "the band's flickering talents". ==Track listing==