Contemporary reviews of "High Holy Disco Mass" were generally negative. Steve Kitson, writing for the
Telegraph & Argus, called the single "repetitive". John Mahoney, also writing for the newspaper, considered the song tedious and criticized its horn section. Michelle Noach of
The Rocket described "High Holy Disco Mass" as "no great feat of daring" but added: "I rest much faith on them to come up with the goods when their time comes (it will)". ==Formats and track listing==